Two Shades of Institutional Investors: Quants vs. Traditional
Nov 12, 2026·,,
·
0 min read
Ron Kaniel
Gideon Saar
Sheridan Titman
Pingle Wang
Abstract
This paper distinguishes the trading behavior of quantitative and traditional institutional investors using a unique NYSE dataset. Quants exhibit positive-feedback trading, while traditional institutions are contrarian. Around earnings announcements, traditional institutions increase trading and reduce agreement, consistent with heterogeneous interpretations of private information, whereas quants reduce activity until new information is incorporated into their models. Traditional institutions also buy before high-uncertainty FOMC announcements, while quants reduce exposure afterward. Trading by quants and traditional institutions also predict returns. Specifically, heavy quant (traditional) trading predicts negative (positive) future returns. Moreover, crowded quant trading predicts return reversals, while uncrowded trading predicts continuation.
Type
